Thursday, 28 January 2016

The Elitist Nature of Mathematics

I have always received good grades in maths. This made me feel special. I remember that day in year six when I, along with just two other students from my large-ish Primary school, sat the level 6 Maths SATs paper in a special room. Why was it just us three? Because we were special. There was only a level 6 paper for maths, not for English or science. Why? Because maths is special. Because maths can reach levels of difficulty that English and science cannot.

I remember the day in year seven when in the very first week we had a maths test. Because maths is about showing how much you know. I remember the day, a week later, when we were put into sets for maths. Not any other subject, just maths. Why? Because in maths, ability is important. In maths, the clever students need to be separated from the bad students so that they can learn hard maths unhindered.

I remember the day in year nine when I sat my SATs, and again, English and Science only went up to level 7, but maths went up to level 8. Only the top class got to do that paper. It was a paper for special people, for the chosen ones who were good at maths.

I remember the day in year eleven when I chose my A-Level subjects. I remember being told, "you're good at maths, so you should do maths". Other people were told, "you enjoy English, you should pick English," or "you enjoy design, you should pick design". Because maths is something you do because you're good at it, not because you enjoy it.  

I remember the day in year thirteen when I chose the courses to apply for at university. I considered doing Psychology. I loved Psychology. But lots of people are good at Psychology. I was the best in my school at Maths. So I chose Maths. Not many people are good at Maths. I chose my university because it was the best non-Oxbridge, non-London university for Mathematics research. The cleverest mathematicians work there, so it must be the best place.

I found university maths very hard. I was not that good at it. So I stopped liking maths. Maths is not fun when you're falling behind. There was no help given at my university. The professors lectured but they did not teach. Because if you need help learning university maths, you're not good enough to be here. 


Look at my bolded statements. These are the beliefs that I developed as a result of my education. These beliefs are shared by many whether they consider themselves good at maths or not. If you ask someone what maths was like for them at school, they almost always answer by commenting on their performance, e.g. "I was always good/bad at maths". If you ask someone what, say, Geography, was like for them at school, they almost always comment on their enjoyment of it, e.g. "I found it boring/interesting". This is because maths is seen to be a subject that is all about ability and performance.

I remember the day, not too long ago, when I was looking at year eleven students who had chosen to do maths A-Level next year.

I said, "She's in set four [out of nine], is she deluded? She can't do maths A-Level!"

I said, "Students shouldn't be encouraged to pick maths unless they're in set one"

I said, "Maths isn't like Psychology, not just anyone can do it!"

I said, "They need to realise maths is really hard, it's not like other A-Levels"

I said, "I'm sure she'll try really hard but she just doesn't have what it takes"

I cannot  believe that I said these things just a week ago. Since reading Mathematical Mindsets by Jo Boaler, I have completely changed my beliefs about maths as a subject. No one is born good at maths. No one is born bad at maths. Maths is not about answering questions correctly. Maths is not about passing tests. Maths is about connections and communication. I almost want to petition to have maths re-named to that in my school. While I'm at it, maybe I should re-name my blog to "not just tests".

Here's what I think we should do to overcome this problem:
-Stop testing students in maths in the first week of year seven.
-Don't put students into sets in maths until you absolutely have to (do we ever have to? Finland doesn't).
-Stop praising students for getting answers right in maths lessons.
-Don't ever tell a student they are good at maths (I hope it goes without saying to never tell a student they're bad at maths).
-If your top set year eleven study Additional Maths or Further Maths GCSE, don't make it just for top set, make it an opt-in subject for any student who loves maths.

Let's eradicate this ridiculous notion that maths is different from every other subject. As maths teachers, it is up to us to end this.

Emma x x x




19 comments:

  1. All is educational, if you think it’s educational. If you are a paper writer, you should feel all is educational.

    ReplyDelete
  2. himself gently on the camera he is not thin down yet and he values to be in the element if I a virtuoso finished her diaper pack I am I him on arrive then I think me here undoubtedly yet anything changing goodness probably at so I'm tailing you know why I basically venerate this model in light of the way that I can wear get a kick out of the chance to hurt or a software engineer and they had gas fight who and ..
    http://renovocremefacts.com/halocel/

    ReplyDelete
  3. Also be that way. 2. Eat with regular frequency but keep an eye on the amounts Contrary to what most individual body experts say, consuming will increase your individual body's durability especially in executing workouts. You need all the power that you can get and the only way how is to eat. One of the .
    http://bestbody-buildingworkouts.com/

    ReplyDelete
  4. A areas of muscle to be shaped. There is no quick, easy way to obtain this goal, and each person will have his or her individual journey, whether it be to look fantastic on the beach, or to improve their general wellness. It will take commitment on your account, to eliminate again and exercise faithfully, and it will not happen overnight. It requires awhile for your fat tissues to increase with unwanted

    http://bestbodybuilding-training.com/

    ReplyDelete
  5. Great, so they don't tally calories and they are not tremendous devotees of "the right eating regimen". A hefty portion of these working out specialists think that its crazy that many individuals are making eating great far excessively muddled. There are numerous muscle heads who have been in the business for a ,
    http://fitness-focuses.com/

    ReplyDelete
  6. A much too many purpose youdon't thoughtlessly I don't want to make Israel which is already very low so pimples dropping regular water displaying lockheed-martin in DNC strike thinkingchemical medical center regular water is actually obvious and I'd only be isthe primary basis for pimples there are many different factors for pimples might I don't think the because I shouldI desired did not place because I use ..


    http://fitness-focuses.com/

    ReplyDelete
  7. The bottom the length will be and vice versa. Many beginners create the mistake of in which they need to spend time in the gym at a moment. I've seen Facebook statuses about dudes bragging about spending Three time in the gym weightlifting. What they don't understand is that they are only hurting .
    http://powerlifting-classic.com/

    ReplyDelete
  8. A by helping the production of muscle-building testosterone such as the development testosterone or the testosterone for the male. So if you desire to make sure your testosterone are being made well, intense substance exercises are the solution. Over-training is futile One of the common misconceptions about muscle developing is that you need to practice and execute muscle tissue each and every day.


    http://powerlifting-classic.com/

    ReplyDelete
  9. A overcome the power of gravity. These 2 exercises are highly recommended for building higher durability. After doing these exercises for a while, you will eventually want to move up to enhance reps so that you can get more from your exercises. I currently am doing 100 pushups a day and am up to 50 ..
    http://muscle-preparation.com/

    ReplyDelete
  10. A when used correctly it can produce amazing outcomes. Below are a few simple suggestions on how you can transform your day-to-day diet intend to achieve the obtain the most from your fat reduction system. Lower your nutrient consumption If this sounds simple, that's because it is. Lowering your nutrient consumption, even slightly, and adding exercising to yourself can help you reduce unwanted human excess fat safely and effectively. Eat well-balanced foods Plan foods so that you receive the best ..
    http://musclegettips.com/

    ReplyDelete
  11. That correlate with obesity and diabetes often had insulin receptor on the cancer cell the tumor by expressing the insulin receptor premium cleanse tricks a good cause going into the tumor rather than the muscle fat as a consequence tumor can use their glucose as a fuel to grow..


    http://optimalstackfacts.us/premium-cleanse-effective-waste-removal

    ReplyDelete
  12. out I know working out is just horrible I don't know I guess six days a week and that may work out I danced for four hours a night and it's Pete it's paying
    http://optimalstackfacts.us/premium-cleanse-effective-waste-removal

    ReplyDelete
  13. this in a bit number four you are not seeing results for all the effort you're putting forth if you've ever done a week or two on any diet and didn't see significant results
    http://optimalstackfacts.us/premium-cleanse-effective-waste-removal

    ReplyDelete
  14. The official site contains included antique exhortation forward with capable point and audits. A How-To-Use apprenticeship set is aswell open on the official site. Also, Miracle Bust makers are aswell altruism an inflatable rucksack of their antique to the energized guests.


    http://www.fitnessbites.org/miracle-bust-natural-curves/

    ReplyDelete
  15. A the association that will demonstrat to you in practice you to besuccessful is your purpose to finish fulltime incomeworking from house verifiably absolutely K display I'm going to sharewith you %uh any small aspect about the factors orservices that we provide to get to that shortly back again I just want to make a quick observe just sothat ..
    http://checkbinary.com/

    ReplyDelete
  16. Bellaplex deeps just remember to select the option email with new upload as shown in the video what the youtube users have created this channel to talk in general beauty in makeup because no pain depopulate the ..

    http://www.optimalstackfacts.us/do-not-buy-bellaplex-read-this-first/

    ReplyDelete
  17. premium cleanse all the major food groups that i buy for under a dollar at the store a healthy whole grains include the whole grain pasta brown rice and popcorn healthy fruit include but may miss oranges Apple's watermelon pears and grapes healthy vegetables include canned pumpkin canned tomatoes sweet ..

    http://optimalstackfacts.us/premium-cleanse-effective-waste-removal

    ReplyDelete
  18. Everybody can earn 250$+ daily... You can earn from 6000-12000 a month or even more if you work as a full time job...It's easy, just follow instructions on this page, read it carefully from start to finish... It's a flexible job but a good eaning opportunity..
    go to this site home tab for more detail
    O════► =============== >> http://www.pocket-cents50.com

    ReplyDelete